Jews and Muslims in the 19th district of Paris: Together or apart?
Author(s)
Publication Name
Publication Date
Abstract
From an intercultural perspective, this article explores majority/minority and between minorities interactions, and revisits Allport’s contact theory, in a socially and ethnically diverse urban area hosting a large proportion of Jews and Muslims. The data comes from a telephone survey of a sample of inhabitants of the 19th arrondissement of Paris. Open and closed questions explore the symbolic social and political boundaries respondents construct between ‘us’ and ‘them’, and their patterns of sociability. Survey experiments with vignettes deal with more sensitive issues (reactions to circulating cartoons at school and police reactions to verbal assault, according to the ethnicity of the victim). The immediate social and ethnic surrounding of each respondent is reconstructed on the basis of census and ethnographic data. The results go against several common beliefs. Religion is not the only dimension of respondents’ identity; it intersects with social class, gender and generation. The relations between Jews and Muslims are not so much conflictual as ambivalent. Being minorities and feeling discriminated against as such brings them together. They both are more religious than the majority population, more traditional on sexual issues and more family-oriented, and most of them consider that Jews and Muslims have a common cultural heritage and should be united against discrimination. Nevertheless, there are friction points (Israeli-Palestinian conflict/the colonial past of France). Politically and socially Muslims are closer to the non-European immigrants, while Jews are closer to the French and the European-born ‘white’ population. Antisemitism is a clear taboo; anti-Jewish cartoons are seen as far more reprehensible than any other. But a majority of the sample, and Muslims a little more than average, see Jews as a ‘group apart’, and believe in the old stereotype about Jews having more influence, being more likely, for instance, to be helped by the police if needed.
Topics
Jewish - Muslim Relations Main Topic: Other Attitudes to Jews Jewish - Non - Jewish Relations Surveys Islam Antisemitism Islamophobia
Genre
Geographic Coverage
Original Language
Page Number / Article Number
28(1)
Related
Introduction: Boundary work in Muslim-Jewish encounters in urban Europe (Part of same special issue)
Music and dance beyond boundaries? Emphasizing Muslim–Jewish North African commonalities, avoiding politics (Part of same special issue)
Urban renewal, contested memories and the politics of cultural production: The case of Jewish–Muslim encounters in Germany (Part of same special issue)
Eating (with) the other: Jewish-Muslim gastronomic encounters (Part of same special issue)
Contestations and cooperation in Muslim–Jewish neighbourhood encounters: A London case study (Part of same special issue)
Music and dance beyond boundaries? Emphasizing Muslim–Jewish North African commonalities, avoiding politics (Part of same special issue)
Urban renewal, contested memories and the politics of cultural production: The case of Jewish–Muslim encounters in Germany (Part of same special issue)
Eating (with) the other: Jewish-Muslim gastronomic encounters (Part of same special issue)
Contestations and cooperation in Muslim–Jewish neighbourhood encounters: A London case study (Part of same special issue)
DOI
Link
Link to article including link to pdf, Jews and Muslims in the 19th district of Paris: Together or apart?
Bibliographic Information
Jews and Muslims in the 19th district of Paris: Together or apart?. 2025: 28(1). https://archive.jpr.org.uk/10.1177/13675494241311095
