The Impact of Communal Intervention Programs on Jewish Identity: An Analysis of Jewish Students in Britain
Author(s)
Publication Name
Publication Date
April 2014
Abstract
During the 1990s, Jewish communal leaders in Britain reached a consensus that Jewish education, in the broadest sense, was the principal means of strengthening Jewish identity and securing Jewish continuity. This belief motivated considerable investment in communal intervention programs such as Jewish schools, Israel experience trips, and youth movements. Twenty years on, it is pertinent to ask whether, and to what extent, this intervention has worked. The Institute for Jewish Policy Research’s (JPR) 2011 National Jewish Student Survey contains data on over 900 Jewish students in Britain and presents an opportunity to empirically assess the impact such intervention programs may have had on respondents’ Jewish identity by comparing those who have experienced them with those who have not. Regression analysis is used to test the theory based on a set of six dimensions of Jewish identity generated using principal component analysis. The results show that after controlling for the substantial effects of Jewish upbringing, intervention has collectively had a positive impact on all aspects of Jewish identity examined. The effects are greatest on behavioral and mental aspects of socio-religious identity; they are far weaker at strengthening student community engagement, ethnocentricity, and Jewish values. Further, the most important intervention programs were found to be yeshiva and a gap year in Israel. Both youth movement involvement and Jewish schooling had positive but rather limited effects on Jewish identity, and short-stay Israel tours had no positive measurable effects at all.
Topics
Genre
Geographic Coverage
Copyright Info
Latest pre-publication draft courtesy of the author
Original Language
Volume/Issue
34(1)
Page Number / Article Number
31-57
Link
Bibliographic Information
The Impact of Communal Intervention Programs on Jewish Identity: An Analysis of Jewish Students in Britain . April 2014: 31-57. https://archive.jpr.org.uk/object-uk44
