The Limits of Tolerance: A Field Experiment at a German University on Bias against the Israeli Flag
Author(s)
Publication Name
Publication Date
5 April 2025
Abstract
In the aftermath of the October 7, 2023 attacks, reports of anti-Israel expressions at German universities have raised questions about the prevalence and nature of such sentiments in academic environments. Traditional survey-based research on antisemitism and anti-Israel sentiment is often limited by response biases and social desirability bias. This study introduces a novel field-experimental approach to measuring anti-Israel sentiment in a real-world university setting. Using event history analysis, it examines the removal probability of stickers of the Israeli flag compared to German, US, Palestinian, and rainbow flags at a German university. Over a 24-week period, 600 stickers were placed on 50 public notice boards and were monitored for 14-day cycles. The results provide strong evidence of anti-Israel sentiment. The Israeli flag had the highest removal rate, with only 47.5% of the flags remaining at the end of the observation period—significantly lower than the survival rates of the other flags (which range from 68% to 80%). Cox regression analysis confirms that Israeli flags faced the highest removal hazard, being 3.3 to 3.7-times more likely to be removed than the rainbow flag and nearly twice as likely as the German flag. Politically motivated removals, though less frequent, disproportionately targeted Israeli flags as well. Removal rates were highest in hallways of the humanities, shared humanities/social sciences as well as in central facilities hallways. Hallways in the natural sciences, the human- and social sciences and economics had lower removal rates. Areas with higher student traffic exhibited fewer removals. Overall, the findings indicate a pronounced anti-Israel bias on campus, distinct from attitudes toward other nationalities or symbols.
Topics
Universities / Higher Education Students Experiments Main Topic: Antisemitism Antisemitism: Israel-Related Attitudes to Israel Israel Criticism
Genre
Geographic Coverage
Copyright Info
CC-By Attribution 4.0 Internationa
Original Language
DOI
Link
Bibliographic Information
The Limits of Tolerance: A Field Experiment at a German University on Bias against the Israeli Flag. 5 April 2025: https://archive.jpr.org.uk/10.31235/osf.io/hcr4y_v1
